Are there Brown's in Winni? I have always been told that there are none, I am reading on another site that people are catching them regualarly out of Winni.
Thansk guy's!

Negitive, Sounds like these guys are keeping male landlocks.............BAD,BAD!! Last year during ice fishing season I stopped at a bobhouse that was right on the beach in gilford and just asked how they were doing and they said only 1-fish and it was a brown trout plus it was long and skinny I then said guys you have a male salmon you better watch what your doing here. They showed it to me and for sure a male landlock was in there bobhouse. I got on my sled and got the hell out of there.

C.C.

I knew as much but wanted to hear it from here.....
There are guy's swearing up and down they catch browns from Winni... I just want to laugh at them.... I will agree sometimes it difficult to tell the difference, but just look at the rows of teeth and that will tell you right away...
Thansk for the input!!

As far as I'm concerned not true fisherman!!!! If you don't know what you have "RELEASE" it, Or learn how to distinguish between certain fish species. Take Care God Bless LOL Dave

You probably saw my response on the other site.... I don't claim to know everything but I have never seen or heard of a brown coming out of winni.
That being said I had never seen or heard of a brookie coming out of their either until my friend caught one. Brookies can and will get into about any lake or pond though.... browns not so much unless someone put them their.

Yes there are browns and brookies in Winni.
This topics has been brought up before on this site. I have caught the occasional brown trout out of Winni and yes I do know the difference (part of my college studies in fisheries was how to use a dichotomus key to indentify fish species.)

I can remember in years past catching brookies @ Glendale and some big brookies where Gunstock River flows into Winni.

Boys,

As many of you do, I have 30 plus years of fishing winni for salmon and lakers. In the mix we all get the rainbow trout, but i assure you once in a great while you will catch something weird. I am certain that in 1991 I caught a 19" brown trout in wolfeboro bay. I have also caught an 18" fish when trolling that with the help from a book, may have been a "shad" ? or a hugely overgrown shinner. also in wolfeboro bay area when spring fishing for salmon.

I hate to be so negative but I really would advise against even insinuating that there are browns in Winni. Like C.C. said in a previous post, I have met people who have sworn to have caught browns and they were post spawn male salmon. And yes I also got the heck out of there. I have also seen brookies caught out of Winni. If even there was a remote chance of one getting thrown in, I cringe at the thought of anglers removing salmon from holes thinking they might be salmon. The fishery is so fragile as it is, so please anglers cut the line. As a side note, I would love to get fish and game's take on this issue.

Thanks,
Tibbs

thinking they might be browns that is. mistype.

I was on a charter once with a friend along with my Dad and a few other people, this particular day the young man on board caught a beautiful male salmon (this was last weekend before end of season) and I'll tell ya what if it had not been for the captain of the boat I too would have sworn it was a brown, and yes it did have red spots on it, it was very dark compared to other salmon caught that day. An occasional brookie I could see (possibly a native) coming into the lake from the many creeks/rivers but Personally have never heard of anyone catching a brown and I know many people who have fished the lake for many years, I'm not saying anyones a liar, but I'd love to see a true pic, or as someone else said hear F&G take on the matter. Take Care God Bless LOL Dave P.S. if its the same pic I saw on another website it sure looked like a salmon to me????

Here is a couple stories, ice fishermen with a huge spawned out salmon on the ice calling out "hey pal what kind of fish is this" as I approached a 20+" brown colored salmon ( Spawned out colors) laying on the ice, what a specimen!!, as these flownders had no idea what they have......"PUT IT BACK IN"

My dad, in his 60's, fished all his life!! caught.. in a trout pond in NH, a 7+ lb brown and claimed it was a salmon.... in print in the Ossipee paper WITH A PICTURE! they proudly presented a land lock salmon! Myself never seeing the picture looked in the freezer to see the great fish. It was carfully wraped to show it distinctly had a SQUARE TAIL!!!! I exclaimed "YOU KNUCLEHEAD!!!" thats a brown trout! I then carefully photo copied the yearly fishing manual of NH to the tune of 30+ and pasted them through out the fishing camper to remind them there is a difference between Salmon and Brown trout!!!

Both true recollection!!

Take a good look at the home page and look at saltys spawned out male salmon,

C.C.

I am not insinuating that I've caught browns in Lake Winni, I know for a fact that I've caught browns in Lake Winni; not many over the years but brown trout non the less. Yes, people get the two species confused, you ought to read Ice Shanty.com last year re: browns vs.LL salmon in Little Ossipee Lake. Certainly not encouraging people to kill first and ID later.

I remember catching little salmon in Gunstock River and being told they were brown trout and talking to fishermen who had killed the little salmon and kept them as part of their 10 trout limit (thinking they were browns). (Skip DeHart of DeHart Farm, Old Lakeshore Rd., Gilford, caught a 7lb + rainbow from the Gunstock River back in the late 60's, a rainbow this size back then out of that little stream surprised a lot of people!)

Having grown up on Lake Winni I can remeber a time when there: "no largemouths in Lake" except I caught my first largemouth in 1967 @ Smith Cove proving the "experts" wrong.

There are now bluegills, rock bass and black crappie in the Lake; remember when there weren't any in Lake Winni?

Point to this rambling: What we knew yesterday may not be true tomorrow. Keep an open mind and tone down the dogma.

I personally am keeping an open mind and am pretty sure I stated that in my post? "I'm not saying anyones a liar, but I'd love to see a true pic, or as someone else said hear F&G take on the matter." Didn't mean to offend anyone!!!!!!!! Take Care God Bless LOL Dave

I know there are a lot of knowledgeable fishermen on this website which I truly enjoy reading posts from. However there are, how can I put it not so delicately, ignorant and uninformed anglers as well. I know there are Browns in Ossipee Lake and I've caught a few browns in my time, not that I fish for them all that often. I just don't want one's open mind to become a can of worms and could ever so slightly open the door to the senseless taking of seasonally protected fish. The best way I think to tell the difference is: brown trout (as one previous poster nicely put it) have square tails and salmon have forked tails. I think perhaps I've seen too many people who were uninformed and those who just don't care perhaps?? My dad was a conservationist first and taught me that when in doubt throw it back. Is it really worth the revokation of your license because you couldn't correctly identify a fish? Or maybe, like boating licensing, there should be a course fisherman must pass in order to be granted a license. I hate to harp on the issue but I love to fish for salmon and hate to see this fishery adversely affected by the notion that an unrecognized, Winni species is somehow present. Could one have been caught? Anything's possible. I think F&G would say (and not to put words in their mouths) but they would probably say something like, "we do not stock brown trout in Lake Winnipesaukee and more often than not it's a question of misidentification." And yes I acknowledge that there are exceptions to the rule. A heck of a lot of species reside in this lake that were not intended to be here.

I once caught a salmon in Mirror Lake in Melvin Village through the ice. Knew it wasn't stocked. Could it have been 'put' there by someone, sure. There is a small stream that connects it to Winni so it is also possible that was the case. Just my.....100 cents....lol. I don't ordinarily ramble but as you may have noticed, seen too many people who were not informed... Glad for the chance to voice myself and appreciate the dialogue taking place.

Tibbs

I've caught male salmon that have squared tails. They're not all forked

Just look at Salty's on the home page if you want to see a square tail salmon.
Cal

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

I've caught male salmon that have squared tails. They're not all forked

Who knows what's in Winni or how they got there, all I know is Fish and Game do not put any Browns in any Salmon Lakes, except one (maybe more) of the Connectticut Lakes and it's done for that reason they can be hard to tell the difference, allthough it shouldn't be that hard.

John S.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

Just look at Salty's on the home page if you want to see a square tail salmon.
Cal

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

I've caught male salmon that have squared tails. They're not all forked

The biggest problem that we have here as sportsman and Woman is if people start to "think" there are Browns in Winni we are all going to see our great fishery take a hard hit. People will keep Salmon as "browns" all year round not knowing what they have caught!!! That is the fear I have! Furthermore I have been fishing the lake for many years and have never caught one, I did however catch a Brook Tout once. I'm not saying there is NO way there has ever been a Brown in Winni I am saying that if you start this type of chatter you might as well kiss our fishery good bye!

My 2 cnets

And I think White Perch Assasin words say it all, If in doubt "Please release the Fish" God know's it took me long enough to finally start catching fish on winni I surely don't want to see the fishery hurt. Take Care God Bless LOL Dave

From Ice Shanty.com

This is what F & G said about browns in Winni.

Hi James

We purposely do not stock any waters in the Winnipesaukee watershed with brown trout, due to the identification of the brown trout and the similarities with landlocked salmon. That being said, in nature it is impossible to say with a 100% certainty that some brown trout at Powder Mill Hatchery may "jump the racks" into the pools of rainbow trout that eventually may be destined for Lake Winnipesaukee. These chances are slim indeed as fish culturists often keep the pools segregated from different species.

Good luck out there!

Don Miller

Donald Miller
Large Lake Fisheries Biologist
New Hampshire Fish and Game Department
Region 2
New Hampton NH 03256
(603) 744-5470
donald.miller@wildlife.nh.gov

It shouldn't hurt the fishery thyat much if someone keeps a Salmon thinking it's a Brown as the Season is April 1st to September 30th, for all Trout and Salmon in any Salmon/Trout lake, period.

But I suppose if they keep one when ice fishing, thinking it's a Brown, it might have some impact ????

Like Miller said and I read it somewhere else myself, I looked and couldn't find it again, but I know I read it. They purposely do not mix these two fish in Lakes because of the identification problem. Sure an occaisional Brown or Brook trout could be put in by mistake, but I think it's more an identification problem.

In the rule book (pg 67) it explains the difference between adult Salmon and Brown, check it out, there are several very easily recognised differences. The tail is not really "forked" on a Salmon, but it is not squared and has pointy tips where a Brown has more rounded tips. But the easiest things to spot are upper jaw on a Brown extends well behind the eye and the upper jaw on the Salmon does not go past the eye. Reddish/Orange Adipose fin on the Brown, spots on the Dorsal fin on the Brown, etc.

I would say if you had the two side by side, the difference would be very obvious.

Accidents do happen, but hows the saying go "ignorance of the laws is no excuse". Anyone caught with a fish they are not supposed to have will loose their license period. So we should know what we are fishing for.

Being bored all winter I read the rule book a few times, lol. Boy does that book need some work on better clarification of many statements and rules.

John S.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

The biggest problem that we have here as sportsman and Woman is if people start to "think" there are Browns in Winni we are all going to see our great fishery take a hard hit. People will keep Salmon as "browns" all year round not knowing what they have caught!!! That is the fear I have! Furthermore I have been fishing the lake for many years and have never caught one, I did however catch a Brook Tout once. I'm not saying there is NO way there has ever been a Brown in Winni I am saying that if you start this type of chatter you might as well kiss our fishery good bye!

My 2 cnets

"I would say if you had the two side by side, the difference would be very obvious."

Thank you John Sampson.

The above scenario was exactly what happen the last time I caught a brown in Winni; fishing in the spring caught (3) LL salmon & (1) brown and when you have them side by side in spring colors (silver!) the differnce is obvious. yes, I was surprised to catch a brownie out of Winni.

As far as confusing browns & salmon and harming the fishery let me tell you I've seen a lot of people that confused rainbow trout (silver phase) w/ salmon & vice versa. In fact I've seen people that confused fallfish in their spawning colors w/ rainbow trout.

I personally feel that NH F&G should pick one of the larger lakes designated as a salmon lake (not located in Pittsburgh, NH.) and make it into a trophy brown trout fishery. Brown trout have a much better chance of reaching trophy size(8 lbs. plus)than an Atlantic Salmon does. Any doubt on this, check out the Finger Lakes in NY and see the pig browns they catch out of them(10lbs plus are not that rare). I've caught a 7lb brown out of Ossippee about 8 years ago but have never hooked another one since. I love to fish for salmon but as I continue to hone my skills I find myself wanting a shot at catching bigger fish and not as many numbers. I feel browns could afford us this opportunity in NH., if given the chance. I feel that our state is now stocked to produce numbers and not size. That's my experience on Winni. the last 3-4 years. Overall, I'm not saying numbers are a bad thing. I just wish we had more lakes managed for trophy fish and not every large lake HAS TO have salmon as it's primary stocked fish. I hope F&G reads this site and I'm interested to see if I'm the only person that feels this way.

Thanks,
Chris

Fish and Game realize what you are saying, they give the anglers what they want and most Winni people want NUMBERS. If we want bigger fish in Winni they will have to drasticaly reduce the stocking rate, any mention of this and I'm sure it would cause a major riot.

There are some lakes that are managed as trophy lakes, Squam Lake being one of them and Sunapee has a good number of bigger fish, Winnisquam has somewhat a reduced stocking rate of Salmon. Winni gets tons of fish and that's what it seems most people want.

I do agree with you 100% that a GOOD Brown Trout Lake
is an excellent idea, if biologicaly possible and doable. I'm sure if you or anyone was to start a petition or some way to make your desires known, you would be heard.

John S.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

I personally feel that NH F&G should pick one of the larger lakes designated as a salmon lake (not located in Pittsburgh, NH.) and make it into a trophy brown trout fishery. Brown trout have a much better chance of reaching trophy size(8 lbs. plus)than an Atlantic Salmon does. Any doubt on this, check out the Finger Lakes in NY and see the pig browns they catch out of them(10lbs plus are not that rare). I've caught a 7lb brown out of Ossippee about 8 years ago but have never hooked another one since. I love to fish for salmon but as I continue to hone my skills I find myself wanting a shot at catching bigger fish and not as many numbers. I feel browns could afford us this opportunity in NH., if given the chance. I feel that our state is now stocked to produce numbers and not size. That's my experience on Winni. the last 3-4 years. Overall, I'm not saying numbers are a bad thing. I just wish we had more lakes managed for trophy fish and not every large lake HAS TO have salmon as it's primary stocked fish. I hope F&G reads this site and I'm interested to see if I'm the only person that feels this way.

Thanks,
Chris

I agree with John. People in large do want quantity over quality of fish. Theoretically both could be done with perhaps an increase in the minimum length limit. I've heard a few folks mention length limits before and there very well may be a reason the idea has not been taken more seriously. I've thought for a couple of years that the minimum size for rainbow trout should be changed to 17 or 18 inches too. I'm with you Chris, I'd prefer to catch fewer and bigger fish. We just happen to be in the minority.

I am, as if my previous posts weren't clear, against the introduction of brown trout into Lake Winnipesaukee. I feel like a protective parent of this lake and the salmon are my kids (kindof a corny analogy). There are certainly many other species of fish that are misidentified for others too. I just know how salmon are such suckers through the ice and are by law not to be taken out of the water. Now looking at a fish's head, can you be sure what you're heaving out of the water is one species or another? If all of a sudden anglers are thinking they have a brown trout, that fish is now out of the water with a possible hook would and being a fragile fish anyways. Rainbow trout consequently have a pinkish stripe down the side.

I have emailed fish and game to get their take on whether or not there are any waterways stocked with Brown trout that lead into Winni. I will never claim to know every nook and cranny so it's possible that might be how one got in or perhaps a couple got in with a salmon stocking? Also I asked if there have been any documented browns caught and if there were pictures as well.

By the way does anyone know how many salmon are currently stocked in Winni? Rainbows too? Thanks all.

Tibbs

Depends on the size they come from the hatchery, they stock by the "pound", bigger fish less fish go in. I think it's normally 20,000+, but last year they were smaller so it could have been 25,000 or more. No clue on the Bows.

They tried longer length on Squam and it did not work out, reduced stocking rates are the best way and I would never want to be the person suggestting that for Winni, they would lynch you fer sure, lol.

Salmon upper jaw does not go beyond the eye and a Brown goes well past the eye, similar to large and Smallouth Bass. But I don't know if you could tell he difference in the hole as I don't ice fish at all anymore. When I did years ago, we didn't really catch any fish, just sat on a milk crate, drank Brandy and had a hell of a time, fish or not.

John S.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

I agree with John. People in large do want quantity over quality of fish. Theoretically both could be done with perhaps an increase in the minimum length limit. I've heard a few folks mention length limits before and there very well may be a reason the idea has not been taken more seriously. I've thought for a couple of years that the minimum size for rainbow trout should be changed to 17 or 18 inches too. I'm with you Chris, I'd prefer to catch fewer and bigger fish. We just happen to be in the minority.

I am, as if my previous posts weren't clear, against the introduction of brown trout into Lake Winnipesaukee. I feel like a protective parent of this lake and the salmon are my kids (kindof a corny analogy). There are certainly many other species of fish that are misidentified for others too. I just know how salmon are such suckers through the ice and are by law not to be taken out of the water. Now looking at a fish's head, can you be sure what you're heaving out of the water is one species or another? If all of a sudden anglers are thinking they have a brown trout, that fish is now out of the water with a possible hook would and being a fragile fish anyways. Rainbow trout consequently have a pinkish stripe down the side.

I have emailed fish and game to get their take on whether or not there are any waterways stocked with Brown trout that lead into Winni. I will never claim to know every nook and cranny so it's possible that might be how one got in or perhaps a couple got in with a salmon stocking? Also I asked if there have been any documented browns caught and if there were pictures as well.

By the way does anyone know how many salmon are currently stocked in Winni? Rainbows too? Thanks all.

Tibbs

LOL. You know some days I should have stayed home and watched football or hockey rather than freeze my butt off. Thanks for information John. Very interesting to learn they stock them by the pound. I was going to guess around 20,000 salmon. I asked about rainbows because I figured with the increased fishing for them, especially durin the Meredith Rotary fishing derby that they could perhaps stock a few more or even a few larger fish. And yes I concur we could be lynched for suggesting fewer salmon be stocked. I am with you, would rather see less, bigger fish stocked. Would certainly test our luck and our salmon fishing IQs. Though not sure I want my salmon intelligence put to the test. Could damage a man's ego. lol.

Tibbs

If you want to go for maybe bigger fish then try Sunapee or Squam, allthough this years netting results showed some bigger Salmon from Winni ????

I like numbers, but bigger is better, as they say.

John S.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

LOL. You know some days I should have stayed home and watched football or hockey rather than freeze my butt off. Thanks for information John. Very interesting to learn they stock them by the pound. I was going to guess around 20,000 salmon. I asked about rainbows because I figured with the increased fishing for them, especially durin the Meredith Rotary fishing derby that they could perhaps stock a few more or even a few larger fish. And yes I concur we could be lynched for suggesting fewer salmon be stocked. I am with you, would rather see less, bigger fish stocked. Would certainly test our luck and our salmon fishing IQs. Though not sure I want my salmon intelligence put to the test. Could damage a man's ego. lol.

Tibbs

If the netting results are true then I must have been fishing the wrong part of Winni! I do remember you saying and posting pictures of some nice looking salmon from Squam. Are the figures for Fall netting on F&G's website? I also would like to thank you again for the downrigger boom you sent me for my Cannon mini-mag. Although I have yet to find the time to put it on I will certainly be grateful that I have it come late spring. Let's hope for the warmer temps and I at least would like to see a good run off so salmon fishing in the Smith River in the Wolfeboro area will be dynamite. In other words, let the snow melt but not all at once.

Tibbs

I don't think you will find it on the F and G web site, John Viar usually sends it to the Winni web site and AJ oast it. Or you can e mail F and G and they will send it to you. I have it and if I can find it, I'll send it along, but it is public record.

Which boom did I send you, the 24" or 36", I still have 2 spare booms, 1 of the 24" I will give with my now sold riggers as a spare, if you have the 36" one I'll hold it for you or anyone else that might need one.

John S.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

If the netting results are true then I must have been fishing the wrong part of Winni! I do remember you saying and posting pictures of some nice looking salmon from Squam. Are the figures for Fall netting on F&G's website? I also would like to thank you again for the downrigger boom you sent me for my Cannon mini-mag. Although I have yet to find the time to put it on I will certainly be grateful that I have it come late spring. Let's hope for the warmer temps and I at least would like to see a good run off so salmon fishing in the Smith River in the Wolfeboro area will be dynamite. In other words, let the snow melt but not all at once.

Tibbs

John, any word on that Otter Boat? JoeG