Ice Hockey DBoard

The Official New England Ice Hockey DBoard 

Visit The DBoard Online Store - https://www.cafepress.com/icehockeydboard

Click Here to Visit Our Facebook Page

email: icehockeydboard@yahoo.com

Junior & College Hockey
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: Makar

I don't follow pro hockey since the kneeling incident a couple years ago, so I don't know you Makar compares with the guys on my list, but here is my off-the-cuff list of great NHL players to also play NCAA

Chelios

St Louis

Karia

Hull

Oates

Belfour

Dryden

Anderson

Leetch

Towes

Smolinski

Brind'Amour

Bishop

leClair

Tkachuck

Amonte

Broten

Mullen

Suter

Joseph

Pavelski


I'm quite sure I missed several very good players, but that is what I came up with off the top of my head.


Re: Makar

Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.

Re: Makar

ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close

Re: Makar

Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.

Re: Makar

Let's talk about it over some Makar's Mark bourbon.

Re: Makar

ANON
Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.
Makar will win the next 5

Re: Makar

Anon
ANON
Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.
Makar will win the next 5
Very possible, but until then, you can't disregard Fox.

Re: Makar

ANON
Anon
ANON
Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.
Makar will win the next 5
Very possible, but until then, you can't disregard Fox.
Fox is solid. But, Makar -

Cale Makar is something else. Different level.

Re: Makar

anon
ANON
Anon
ANON
Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.
Makar will win the next 5
Very possible, but until then, you can\'t disregard Fox.
Fox is solid. But, Makar -

Cale Makar is something else. Different level.
Makar is on a different level style points wise. No denying he is flashier than Fox but at the end of the day, their production is very similar and last time I looked, style points don't count for much of anything. It is production.

Re: Makar

Both are going to be great defensemen going forward. Fox has great IQ and passing ability, and is the right spot defensively. Makar physical talent if off the chart, and has outstanding speed, there was a reason why Makar was out on the ice every time McDavid was

Re: Makar

ANON
anon
ANON
Anon
ANON
Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.
Makar will win the next 5
Very possible, but until then, you can\\\'t disregard Fox.
Fox is solid. But, Makar -

Cale Makar is something else. Different level.
Makar is on a different level style points wise. No denying he is flashier than Fox but at the end of the day, their production is very similar and last time I looked, style points don't count for much of anything. It is production.
Makar is arguably the best player in the NHL right now. I know morons on the D board will disagree but thats a fact

Re: Makar

Go watch the twitter clip from 9:44pm EST, 6/13/22. I rest my case and to the guy that thinks Fox is close.. he’s not

Re: Makar

Makar is to D what McDavid is (was) to offense.

In a pool of talented professional athletes they are both on a different level.

That said, if you are ranking NHL D men Makar is clearly the most talented but Fox is likely number 2.

I doubt I would spend millions more of valuable salary cap to get Makar over Fox. Equal pay though I would definitely take Makar.

Re: Makar

Anon
ANON
anon
ANON
Anon
ANON
Anonymous
ANON
Anon
Think he is the best NCAA player to ever play in NHL!
Adam Fox is better.
Fox is better than Makar? Not even close
Saying Makar is better is fine but saying it is not even close is just plain ignorant. Fox won the Norris recently.
Makar will win the next 5
Very possible, but until then, you can\\\\\\\'t disregard Fox.
Fox is solid. But, Makar -

Cale Makar is something else. Different level.
Makar is on a different level style points wise. No denying he is flashier than Fox but at the end of the day, their production is very similar and last time I looked, style points don\'t count for much of anything. It is production.
Makar is arguably the best player in the NHL right now. I know morons on the D board will disagree but thats a fact
Who won the Norris last year?

Re: Makar

And Makar’s production is better. All 31 teams would take Makar over Fox….including the Rangers.

Re: Makar

MAKAR!!!!!!!!

Re: Makar

He’s fun to watch, got to watch him out here in sticks at the zoo. If he stays healthy hell have Bobby Orr type numbers. Enjoy the show.